Braidwood Management v. Becerra

Case Number: 4:20-cv-00283-O N.D. Tex.


Former President Barack Obama and his allies in Congress created section 2713 of the Affordable Care Act, which empowered the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (“PSTF”) to decide the “preventative care” that all private health insurance must cover, even though none of the Task Force’s members were appointed as “officers of the United States” in conformity with Article II of the Constitution. In effect, the PSTF amounted to an unelected, unaccountable group of elite technocrats who unilaterally dictated which services all Americans with health insurance must subsidize—resulting in higher premiums and disruptions to the healthcare system in the United States.


AFL represented clients in a lawsuit seeking to have this section of the Affordable Care Act vacated as violating the Constitution’s Appointments Clause.


The District Court agreed with AFL’s claims that the PSTF violated the Appointments Clause and vacated all of its actions since 2010. The case is now on appeal at the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit.

Stay Informed

Get updates about the legal battles we are waging across the country. To Get Critical Updates By Text: Text Join to 50608.

    I would like to Subscribe!