WASHINGTON, D.C. – Today, America First Legal (AFL), along with its co-counsel at Boyden Gray PLLC, filed a brief in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit supporting Douglass Mackey’s right to free speech.
Douglass Mackey was convicted in federal court in New York for posting satirical memes on the internet–under the statute generally referred to as the Ku Klux Klan Act. This selective prosecution by the Biden Administration’s Department of Justice (DOJ) comes amid the DOJ’s failure to charge progressive activists for doing the exact same thing and its larger efforts to prosecute and use the government against political opponents.
Speech about elections and political rivals – even if misleading or inaccurate, and especially satirical speech – is as old as democracy itself, yet no one ever thought Section 241 made that a crime. In its brief, AFL noted that it is “telling that the government has cited no cases where section 241 has been applied to deceptive speech on any topic.”
In its brief, AFL argues:
- The government stretches Section 241 beyond its universally recognized limits;
- The government’s rewrite of Section 241 will be impossible to apply narrowly;
- The government’s interpretation lacks meaningful limits;
- The government’s interpretation of Section 241 invites selective prosecution;
- The government’s use of improper venue compounds concerns about the government’s interpretation of Section 241.
The government’s application of Section 241 opens Pandora’s box and effectively places no limitation on how it could be applied in the future. AFL argues that the government’s interpretation of the word “injure” in this context is without support in the statute or historical practice. AFL is proud to continue the fight against government targeting of conservative free speech.
Read the brief here.
Photo credit: zimmytws / Adobe Stock
