Randall Dill was a top-performing consultant at International Business Machines Corporation (IBM) with stellar client feedback until July 2023, when he was unexpectedly placed on a Performance Improvement Plan and subsequently fired. At the same time, IBM executives were under corporate pressure to meet diversity quotas that rewarded hiring and firing based on race and sex. Dill, a white male, fit none of those criteria.
America First Legal (AFL) sued IBM under Title VII and the Civil Rights Act of 1964 for race- and sex-based disrcimination. The case has been settled, sending a clear message: companies cannot prioritize diversity targets over federal civil rights laws.