Back to Litigation

Dill v. IBM

Case No. 1:24-cv-00852
Western District of Michigan Southern Division
Status: Closed
Filed: August 2024

What's at Stake

Randall Dill was a top-performing consultant at International Business Machines Corporation (IBM) with stellar client feedback until July 2023, when he was unexpectedly placed on a Performance Improvement Plan and subsequently fired. At the same time, IBM executives were under corporate pressure to meet diversity quotas that rewarded hiring and firing based on race and sex. Dill, a white male, fit none of those criteria.

America First Legal (AFL) sued IBM under Title VII and the Civil Rights Act of 1964 for race- and sex-based disrcimination. The case has been settled, sending a clear message: companies cannot prioritize diversity targets over federal civil rights laws.

Press Releases

AFL in the News

AFL In The News • August 21, 2024 • Daily Mail

‘I was fired from IBM because I’m a white man.’ – How Diversity Targets Ruined My Career

“The way Randall Dill tells it, he was a ‘model employee’ for IBM, nurturing relationships with the Pentagon and other big spenders. Then came the diversity targets, and the Michigander was kicked out of the computing giant so it could hire more women and minorities, he says.”

“In doing so, IBM violated the 1964 Civil Rights Act, said Dill’s lawyer, Gene Hamilton, a director at America First Legal (AFL).”

 

AFL In The News • August 28, 2024 • Daily Mail

‘I was fired from IBM because I’m a white man.” – How Diversity Targets Ruined my Career

The way Randall Dill tells it, he was a ‘model employee’ for IBM, nurturing relationships with the Pentagon and other big spenders. Then came the diversity targets, and the Michigander was kicked out of the computing giant so it could hire more women and minorities, he says.”

AFL In The News • March 26, 2025 • Reuters

IBM must face white worker’s lawsuit over diversity goals

“A federal judge in Michigan on Wednesday refused to dismiss a lawsuit accusing IBM of forcing out a white male consultant in order to further its goals of building a more diverse workforce.

“Andrew Block of America First Legal, the conservative group representing Dill, said: ‘We look forward to continuing to litigate this case and fight for justice on behalf of our client.’

America First Legal was founded by Stephen Miller, a top adviser to Republican President Donald Trump, and has filed a series of lawsuits and complaints claiming companies’ diversity policies are unlawful. In one of those cases, a federal judge in Los Angeles last year rejected CBS’ motion to dismiss a white screenwriter’s claims that the network’s diversity efforts led it to deny him a staff position on the show ‘SEAL Team.'”

AFL In The News • July 7, 2025 • Law 360

IBM Settles White Worker’s ‘Reverse Discrimination’ Suit

IBM has agreed to resolve a white male ex-consultant's bias claims that he was fired so that the company could hire women and people of color to fulfill workforce diversity quotas, according to a filing in Michigan federal court Monday.

The judge found Dill put forward enough detail to support a "reverse discrimination" case — when a man says he has faced gender bias, or a white person says they've faced racial bias — by showing he may have been mistreated for being a part of the "majority."

Dill is represented by Andrew J. Block, Ryan T. Giannetti and Laura M. Stell of America First Legal Foundation and Christopher S. Berry of Smith Haughey Rice & Roegge.

Documents

JOIN THE FIGHT FOR AMERICA'S FUTURE

Get updates about the legal battles we are waging across the country.

Or Text "Join" to 50608
Campaign Overlay